Monday, January 24, 2011

Words mean things

Governor Sammy joins a fundamentalist cult:
It has now been established that Sam Brownback, R-Kan is a member of the Family or C Street. It is a religious cult that many member of the US congress belong to...

As the Republican Party implodes the public is becoming aware of a secretive Christian society known as the Family or the Fellowship. The group was founded in 1935 in opposition to FDR's New Deal and its adherents subscribe to a far right Christian fundamentalist and free market ideology.
I very much enjoy the moonbat's lack of respect for the integrity of words.

For example, a cult (latin:cultus) is generally a group which is separated from the main by a particular devotion, practice, or doctrine.  For example, among Catholics you might have the cult of Saint Oswald or of Saint Dagobert - and these tiny groups would be offset from the whole body by their particular devotion. Within protestantism, cults are similarly divided from the whole. Mormons are considered a cult while the New England Evangelical Baptist Fellowship, composed of but 10 churches and 600 people, is not. What makes the difference? Cults operate outside the "acceptable" limits of Protestant doctrine.

Secondly, fundamentalist is not a synonym for "bad." Fundamentalism in Christian theology was a turn-of-the-20th century Protestant reaction to liberal theology or the Social Gospel, which attempted to dress Progressive do-goodism in religious garb. Fundamentalism promoted the historical "fundamentals" of Protestantism (e.g. inerrancy of scripture, bodily resurrection, vicarious atonement). In short, fundamentalism represents the doctrinal 'core' of Protestantism.

It is very difficult to posit that one could have a fundamentalist cult, or a cult that follows 'fundamentalist ideology' - they are a contradiction in terms.  Making a practicing Roman Catholic a member of such a Protestant oxymoron just compounds the confusion. Whatever "The Family" is, besides a small ministry that provides fellowship for politicians and operates the annual National Prayer Breakfast, it's probably not one of those.

4 comments:

Professor Hale said...

OMG! They subscibe to free market principles. How unAmerican of them.

The problem here is just as you have described; journalists have changed common language to have nefarious tones so that they do not even remember what the originals mean any longer. To them Fundimentalist = evil.

This would be like calling the Fellowship of Christian Athletes a cult.

JN said...

Far-right = evil too.

CJ said...

The Family is kinda creepy. I got a poster from one of them and checked out their website.

What's confusing to me is that I recall them being some sort of collectivist neo-communal group. Not exactly what I would expect from political conservatives.

Justin said...

Just another Jewish pundit blowing anti-Christian dog whistles.